A Place called Oyster Watcha Meadow  
We have taken reviews from several of the venues from which the houses are booked for your consideration.  It is always our goal to make guests feel like this is their home while they are visiting and our hope is that they will fall in love with the Island and love our special location in the meadow as much as we do.  Many of our guests come back year after year and have become very good friends.   We book From April to November and often Holiday Weeks in the Off Season.  Some Winter Weekends in the Guest house are avaiable for 3 night says.  Winter on the Island has a special magic of its own.  Many winter Island Events and Happenings can be found on the Chamber of Commerce Website
Edgartown Oyster Watcha Meadow           
4 of 12 Positive Reviews
Site:      VRBO.COM  83008       
3 Of 21 Positive Reviews
What a spectacular property!  We have stayed in a number of places on the Island, but this one tops the list.  Paul and Karen are gracious and attentive hosts - at call should the need arise (which it did not)  Everything is even more lovely than the photographs  The house is clean and beautifully decorated and the kitchen wonderfully appointed if you like to cook, which we do often.  The outdoor space is a peaceful oasis with lovely gardens, outdoor shower, pool and hot tub.  We never wanted to leave.  Thank you Karen and Paul for a wonderful family vacation.

We are a family of 4 and stayed for a week in the guest house.  The home was very nicely decorated and comfortable.  It looks just like you see in the photos.  It had all the amenities we needed form the lobster pot to the beach bag, cooler, umbrella and chairs for a day at the beach to kayaks.  The house is down a long road through the woods and we loved arriving home each day to a very quiet heaven away for it all.  It is very very centrally located- 10-20 min to to to almost every town or beach on the Island.  Which was perfect for us as each day we chose a different beach and a different town to explore.  The owners were very helpful in advance with suggestions for everything and very responsive to our long list of quesitons.  Our favorite things.  Coffee and amazing blueberry muffins each morning from Morning Glory Farm, W Tisbury Farmers Market, South Beach, Long Point Trustees Beach, Edgartown Shopping, Lobsters from the Net Result and eating lobsters on the dock at Larsens in Chilmark,  We do hope to return.

The property is in a lovely and quiet location, but only a couple of miles or so from Edgartown shops and restaurants.   It was spotless when we visited and beautifully maintained.  A fantastic kitchen, cozy and comfortable livingroom and a wonderful dining area, the house is filled with light.  The owners Paul and Karen were super helpful and informative but not at all intrusive.  They made sure we had all the information we needed before our visit and then called shortly after we arrived to answer any last mnute questions we had about the property and the Island.  I would have no hesitation in recommending this property to friends or family.  We had a thoroughly enjoyable stay. 
Edgartown Holiday  It seems the Hannigans have thought of everything in these beautifully decorated and perfectly maintained houses.   The kitchen is furnished with everything you may need, cupboards are filled with books and games and the laundry room has a pile of beach towels along with an array of coolers and baskets you may need for a picnic at the beach.  They also provide complete details about running the house and a full 3-ring notebook with restaurant suggestions, maps, and activities available on the Island.  The homes are in a secluded area down a private road about a 10 min drive into Edgartown Village.  You are well located for heading in any direction on the Island.  We were fortunate to have mild mid-May weather - Perfect for biking, hiking and exploring this beautiful Island.
At this time of year the island is opening up for the summer so many stores and restaurants are open but there are no crowds.  We very much enjoyed our stay on Marthas Vineyard.

Fabulous Property!   The owners were great to work with both prior to arrival, and once we were on site.  The houses are immaculate, with everything you could possibly desire.  The two gourmet cooks on our trip were very pleased with the kitchens.  The houses were well appointed, with great furnishings, bedding, and towels.  I would highly recommend this property, and the owners. Thank you Paul and Karen

Oyster Watcha Meadow
Karen and Paul are gracious hosts and they have created an amazing retreat on 3 acres on Marthas Vineyard.  The houses and grounds are perfection.  The homes are stylish, comfortable and beautifully equipped.  They anticipated our every need.  We also cannot say enough about the Island.  There are endless options for the most active families!  We look forward to our next trip there. 

Magical is the only way to describe this home.  Karen and Paul have gone to great legnths to ensure that their guests have an unforgettable experience.  The attention to detail at this property in both the main house and the guest house was truly beyond our expectations.  We were made to feel at home in a pristine, well-appointed and thoroughly equipped home from the moment we reserved the property.   Thank you for making our experience phenomenal.  We will never forget our time in Martha's Vineyard because of our time at Oyster Watcha Meadow.   We hope to return to this magical place in the future.  If we could give more than
5  STARS to a property this would be the one!!   Thank you for making us feel so at home!!  You guys are wonderful hosts and we are happy to have had the opportunity to meet you and enjoy your beautiful home. 
Site:  7211
5  of Many Many Positive Reviews
Martha would be proud! 
We spent a great week at this fabulous two home complex.  The set up with a main house and a guest house was perfect for our two families.  Each house has its own yard, driveway, parking, patio and hot tub.  Our hosts were terrific and extremely helpful throughout our stay.  Pool was great and location in the very center of the Island was good.  You do need a car though.  Thanks Karen, great time had by all.

Thank you Karen and Paul for an amazing vacation in your amazing home.  From our fist contact via email to the return of our security deposit we were totally thrilled with all aspects of renting with you.  We have been to Marthas Vineyard for 10 summers now and we must say your home is by far the most spectacular we have ever rented.  Your attention to detail and understanding of what our every need might be really makes staying at your home special.  We loved the mineral pool, it was our fisrt time using a non- chlorine pool and now we are totally spoiled.   Our favorite beach was Longpoint....
Thank you so much for the suggestion.  After we found it we never went to another beach.  We will be back.  Thanks again for the best vacation ever.

NOT YOUR GENERIC RENTAL......  So true!  Beautiful art work, gardens, furnishings, linens, antiques, lawns and grounds......
not fussy......very comfortable.  We loved every second of it.  Thanks

Thank you for a most memorable vacation.  Your book of Island Suggestions was brilliant.  We have been coming to the Island for years and always just went to Katama South Beach.  We had no idea there were so many beaches we could get to.  On several occasions we had them almost all to ourselves!  The favorite was LONG POINT
Our last day of our vacation there was a seal on the beach, which we all loved.  Thank your for all the effort you put into your cottages.  They are obviously loved and used by a family and are not just "rentals"  We loved how well equpped the kitchens were.  I wish my kitchen at home was so nice.  Before we headed back to England I went out and bought Alclad pots and pans and love them.  We have already booked next summer and hope to now make this a yearly trip.  You have been most helpful.  Thanks again we had a stunning time. 

Perfect  Thank You, Thank You Thank You  we had a magical honeymoon.  We loved the hot tub at night under that huge sky and our morning kayak trips were the best.  What a great spot to start out as husband and wife.  Thanks again for all of your kindness.

Guest Books Messages left in houses
Thanks Karen and Paul   Again we cannot say how much we love coming back to your magical little piece of heaven here on the Island.  It is our place to recharge and reconnect.  7 years now and each time it just gets better and better.  Thank you for always being so helpful and understanding the importance of what vacation time means to our young family and always making everything perfect  in every way.

Dear Karen and Paul   Boo Hoo!  Our third, but no less Idylllic vacation at 34 Jennie Lane has come to an end.  Paul when we spotted  you the other morning and you said "Welcome Home"  this is truly how we feel when we are here.  The anticipaion of spending a week here is what keeps us sane as summer and job stress beging to wear on us.   Thank you as always, for allowing us to call your home "our home"  We had a wonderful time doing a lot of nothing.  Enjoy the rest of this beautiful Autumn and we'll see you again next year.

We forgot there is a sound to the wind
We forgot one can hear the silence
The sun looks warmer
and the sky just blue
We loved  your home.  It seems that every item in it was created with love and appreciation of the good things in life.  Thank  you for a great vacation.

Dear Karen and Paul  We had a fabulous vacation from beginning to end. Thank you for all you did to make it perfect.  So great to meet you.  Some of our highlights were, delicious lobster dinner, shooting stars, cooking as a family with fresh basil fom your garden,  your  fresh homemade pesto you dropped off and Long Point Beach  13 of 14 days.  Too many good times to count.  Always so sad to have to leave.    Glad we signed up already for Back again next year......Have a good winter.